The dangers and absurdity of conversion therapy. Told in the style of tragicomedy, the play follows the story of two boys who are caught having sex while attending a conversion therapy retreat in southern Ohio. Repulsed by the boldness of their actions, the leader of the retreat, Brother Mike, decides to perform an exorcism on one of the boys in order to free him from the demons possessing his eternal soul.
Through a series of exercises, all of which have been found to be actual methods used in conversion therapy, Brother Mike and his partner, Sister Constance, attempt to convert the boys to a heterosexual lifestyle, thus saving them from eternal damnation. However, conflict arises when one of the boys decides to take a stand.